On February 15 CBC issued a statement explaining that it carried fake news about Venezuela – although it does not acknowledge the reporting as fake news.
The fake news involved a CBC report showing the Tienditas Bridge barricaded with trucks and claiming this was a response by the Venezeulan government to block humanitarian aid.
The photo appeared in an article published on its web site on or about February 7 (the article has been updated and now has a date of February 12) to bolster the “case” against the government of Nicholas Maduro. The photo used by CBC and other media was first published by Mike Pompeo in a tweet. The photo, in all likelihood, also appeared in CBC’s television news broadcast.
The problem with the CBC statement is that it fails to admit it carried fake news and its reasons for doing so. It did so to manipulate public opinion and to that damming and serious charge CBC is silent in its retraction of the photo.
As has been documented by media watchdogs CBC was not the only news media to carry this report. Many other western media outlets carried the report and for exactly the same reasons. The truth behind this photo emerged within a day or two of it being tweeted by Pompeo. Among the first to expose it as fake news was the Venezuelan government.
The use of the fake photo first appeared in a CBC article on or about February 7. That article was updated February 12 with this statement at the end:
“This story has been updated to reflect the fact that the Tienditas Bridge between Colombia and Venezuela is an unused border crossing. Built in 2016, the bridge has never officially been opened amid ongoing tensions between the two countries.
Feb 12, 2019 5:21 PM ET”
Published on CBC, Feb 15, 2019
Over the past week or so, the image of a blockaded bridge between Colombia and Venezuela has been all over news sites around the world. It’s been featured in stories describing how the president of Venezuela, Nicolas Maduro, is keeping international food aid from his desperate citizens.
Trouble is, the photo doesn’t tell the full story.
Yes, Maduro ordered the containers be put there, and no, he does not want international aid coming in through that corridor. He maintains there is no food shortage in Venezuela, despite numerous reports to the contrary, including from Human Rights Watch.
But the question is, would that bridge even be used to bring the aid into Venezuela from Colombia if it weren’t blocked?
The bridge, which spans between Cucuta, Colombia, and the town of Pedro Maria Urena in Venezuela, hadn’t been open for years. In fact, it’s never been open.
So, what happened?
On Feb. 6, U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo sent a tweet that drew a lot of attention.
The Venezuelan people desperately need humanitarian aid. The U.S. & other countries are trying to help, but #Venezuela’s military under Maduro's orders is blocking aid with trucks and shipping tankers. The Maduro regime must LET THE AID REACH THE STARVING PEOPLE. #EstamosUnidosVE pic.twitter.com/L4ysYJaM6H
— Secretary Pompeo (@SecPompeo) February 6, 2019
The tweet helped back the U.S. position that Maduro is no longer the legitimate president and must go.
Maduro, who is in his second term as president, declared victory after a 2018 election. His opponents disputed the legitimacy of the election and called for a new vote.
The U.S. (along with Canada, the U,K, and several Latin American countries) expressed concern about Maduro’s legitimacy before he even began his second term. When Juan Guaido, leader of the opposition in the National Assembly, said he would serve as interim president pending new elections, the U.S., Canada and other Western countries were quick to announce their support.
But what Pompeo didn’t say in his tweet — and what many news organizations, including CBC News, didn’t report — was that the bridge in the tweet has never been open to traffic.
Construction of the bridge was finished in 2016, amid already heated tensions between the two countries. But Colombian and Venezuelan authorities could not reach an agreement to open it. Nearby bridges were already being used to smuggle in goods and fuel from Colombia to Venezuela.
You can see the Tienditas Bridge here on Google Maps:
According to Google, the photo was captured in June 2017.
The humanitarian aid Pompeo referred to is currently sitting in warehouses in the Colombian border town of Cucuta. It represents only a fraction of what has been promised from the United States, Canada and other allies of the Venezuelan opposition.
On Tuesday, Guaido announced he will open “a humanitarian corridor” to run caravans of food into Venezuela, but not until Feb. 23. Guaido, who doesn’t control the military or state institutions, didn’t give any details of how or where that would happen.
Some diplomats and opposition allies of Guaido have questioned whether such an undertaking would be possible to accomplish in just 10 days.